What Is Dual Pricing? Is It Good For Your Business?

Thinking about trying out a Dual Pricing program but not sure where to begin? Dual Pricing can offer several advantages for your business, especially if a lot of your customers pay with cash or cards. It’s considered one of the more cost-effective credit processing options available. So, what is dual pricing and how can it benefit your business?

Even with the rise of various payment methods, many customers still prefer using cash. That’s one reason businesses opt for dual pricing. In the following article, we’ll discuss how Dual Pricing works and its potential benefits for your business.

What Is Dual Pricing? Understanding The Concept

Dual pricing involves showing two different prices for an item or service: one for cash and another for credit card payments. Many retailers use this strategy to charge customers based on their chosen payment method. For merchants, dual pricing offers a way to give discounts for preferred payment methods, like cash, encouraging customers to use them and saving on credit card fees. This approach can be especially helpful for small businesses looking to maximize profits.

Beyond just cutting credit card processing costs, dual pricing can also steer customers toward safer or easier payment methods. For instance, merchants might offer discounts for using contactless options like Google Pay or for using debit cards, which are generally more secure and simpler to process than standard credit cards.

What Does It Mean For The Business Owners?

Merchants reap significant advantages from dual pricing, primarily in offsetting costs tied to card acceptance, such as merchant services fees. This strategy aids in cushioning the financial impact on their business, ensuring competitiveness in the market without resorting to widespread price hikes. Moreover, dual pricing serves as an incentive for customers to opt for cash transactions, a method that not only proves more cost-effective for merchants but also assists in curbing fraud risks.

However, despite these merits, merchants grapple with various challenges related to dual pricing. Chief among these are regulatory and legal issues, posing difficulties in ensuring compliance with all applicable laws. Furthermore, effectively communicating the dual pricing policy to customers becomes a potential hurdle, risking confusion and discontent among the customer base.

What Does It Mean To The Customers?

Dual pricing offers several advantages for consumers, especially those opting for cash transactions. By presenting a reduced price for cash payments, merchants encourage customers to choose this method, which is often more cost-effective for businesses and aids in mitigating fraud risks. Moreover, dual pricing contributes to increased transparency, empowering consumers to discern the actual expenses associated with card payments and make well-informed choices about their preferred payment method for goods and services.

However, potential downsides exist. The system might introduce confusion and foster a perception of bias against card users. Additionally, critics argue that dual pricing could be discriminatory, particularly against certain demographics like the unbanked or underbanked individuals who may lack access to cash alternatives.

How Does Dual Pricing Work?

If you’re running a business and want to set dual prices for cash and credit card payments, here’s a simple way to do it. Decide on a cash price for your items. Then, for credit card purchases, just add 4% to that cash price. Your POS system can help you figure this out.

For instance, let’s say you’re selling a $50 product X from your retail store. The cash price stays at $50. But if someone pays with a credit card, it becomes $50 + 4%, which is $52.

The extra 4% covers the costs you incur for processing credit card payments. At checkout, your POS system will show both prices. Once the customer picks their payment type, the POS prints a receipt with the right price listed.

Is Dual Pricing Legal?

In the US, the rules around dual pricing come from both federal and state laws. Federally, the TILA Act makes sure that merchants tell customers about the terms for credit transactions and stops them from treating credit users unfairly. Similarly, the EFTA Act requires clear information on EFT transactions, like using a debit card.

State laws also play a big role. They cover areas like interest rates, sales tax, and protecting consumers. For example, California doesn’t allow surcharging, but Texas does. In places where surcharging is okay, merchants have to be upfront about it and apply the same fee to all credit or debit card users.

To balance out processing fees through dual pricing while staying within the rules, follow these steps:

• Your displayed price should reflect the cost of items when purchased with a credit card. Alternatively, you can show both the cash and credit card prices.
• Adjust the price only when a customer pays with cash at the checkout, not for credit card transactions.
• Clearly communicate the cash discount option using visible signs.
• Utilize a POS system that accommodates dual pricing, allowing distinct card and cash prices for each item you sell.

These are the best practices; however, keep in mind these two common errors merchants commit:

• Setting their prices based on the cash rate and then increasing them at checkout for credit card users.
• Failing to notify customers about the cash payment discount available clearly.

Such practices closely resemble illegal surcharging. Apart from risking the trust of your customers, you also expose your business to potential penalties from local authorities, legal repercussions from credit card companies like Visa and Mastercard, and the possibility of losing your privilege to accept credit card payments.

How Is Dual Pricing Different From Surcharging And Cash Discounting?

Understanding the nuances between dual pricing and surcharging is crucial for financial officers due to their distinct characteristics and legal implications. Surcharging involves adding an extra fee to the purchase price for credit card transactions, while dual pricing showcases a discounted cash price. The key distinction lies in the impact on customer perception—surcharging increases the price, while dual pricing provides a discount.

Moreover, the legality varies; dual pricing is generally permitted nationwide, but surcharging is banned in some states and regulated in others, each with its own maximum surcharge rates. Additionally, credit card brands may have specific rules governing surcharging.

Moving on to the connection between dual pricing and cash discounting, it’s really an interchangeable term—they are essentially the same strategy. Whenever you encounter the term cash discounting, think of it as a dual pricing approach, and vice versa.

Benefits Of Dual Pricing To The Businesses

Various types of businesses, from retail stores to service providers and restaurants, opt for Dual Pricing programs due to the advantages they offer.

• Lowering Costs

Businesses, especially SMBs, often face high credit card processing fees. By adopting a Dual Pricing system, these businesses can significantly reduce, or even eliminate, these fees. When customers pay with a credit card, they cover the associated processing costs. This saving allows small businesses to invest in growth, enhance marketing efforts, or grow their profits.

• Offering Choice to Customers

With Dual Pricing, businesses present two pricing options to customers. Those who opt for cash payments enjoy a discounted rate, while those using credit cards pay a slightly higher amount to account for processing fees. This setup provides customers with more flexibility in how they choose to pay.

• Maintains Consistent Profitability

Traditional transaction fees fluctuate based on a percentage of each sale, leading to unpredictable profit margins for businesses. By adopting Dual Pricing, businesses can stabilize their profit outlook, offering a clearer financial picture for planning and budgeting.

• Streamlines Payment Procedures

Dual Pricing simplifies the payment experience for everyone. By promoting cash transactions, businesses can reduce the likelihood of issues like chargebacks, disputes over pricing, and security concerns related to data breaches or fraud.

• More Cash in Hand

While digital payment methods like contactless and mobile payment options are gaining popularity, cash still holds value. Cash payments are immediate, eliminating the waiting period associated with digital transactions. However, it’s essential to maintain credit payment options for customers, making Dual Pricing a balanced choice for both businesses and consumers.

Things to Consider Before Using Dual Pricing

Thinking about dual pricing for your business? It’s essential to weigh the factors to see if it’s the right fit. Here are some key things to consider:

• Customer’s Payment Habits

Research consistently shows that people tend to spend more when they use a credit card instead of cash. In fact, 81% of consumers favor using cards, and they often spend up to three times more than those using cash.

With the rise of mobile payment options like Google Pay and Apple Pay, which also count as credit card transactions, a dual pricing strategy might not be the best way to cater to your card-using customers. So, the first thing to look at is your customers’ payment habits. If a large portion pays with cash, offering a discount for cash transactions can be a smart move. This way, you can set higher prices for card payments, cover your card processing fees, and keep your cash-paying regulars happy. It’s a win-win situation.

However, if a significant number of customers use credit cards, dual pricing might not be well-received. Especially in upscale businesses or busy city locations, customers might see it as unfair. They might think you’re cutting corners or not valuing their loyalty. After all, your pricing likely already covers various costs like rent and staff wages, so why add an extra charge just for using a card?

• Understanding Your Payment Fees

Before jumping into dual pricing, take a good look at your contract with the payment processor. Sure, raising all your prices might cover credit card fees, but that doesn’t mean you’re getting a good deal on processing.

It’s worth talking things over with your processor to see how you can manage costs without just passing them on to your customers. A good discussion should leave you feeling confident about whether dual pricing is the right move for you.

• Know Your Obligations

Before you start the dual pricing model in your business, it is crucial to know what your obligations are. The first obligation is that you must display both credit card and cash prices clearly on the shelf and customer screen.

You should also have a distinct sign to inform customers about the separate pricing options. Failing to do so can lead to penalties by TILA law which requires you to make cash discounts transparent to the customers

Is Dual Pricing Right For Your Business?

Dual pricing is a pricing approach gaining traction in the U.S. merchant payments sector. It offers merchants a way to counterbalance the expenses tied to card transactions, proving particularly beneficial for small businesses that operate on narrow profit margins.

Your bank imposes various fees for the merchant services and credit card network it provides. Here are some common charges you might encounter when a payment is made through credit cards:

• Interchange Fee: This fee supports the credit card network’s maintenance and enhancement, ensuring secure transactions between you and your customers. Remember, this fee is capped at 2.4%, and it should be disclosed before the transaction occurs.
• POS Terminal Charges: Every time you use your POS system to process card payments, your service provider charges a fee. These costs can vary depending on how they’re calculated.
• Forex Conversion Fee: If your business serves international customers, your bank will deduct a fee for converting foreign currencies into your local currency.
• Chargeback Fee: Should a customer challenge a credit card payment, perhaps due to unmet expectations, you’ll incur a chargeback fee from your bank.

As you can clearly see the unnecessary charges, which you can totally avoid by accepting cash. This approach empowers businesses to select the payment strategy that aligns with their business needs. Importantly, if a merchant experiments with Dual Pricing and later prefers to return to Traditional Pricing, the switch is straightforward, cost-free, and doesn’t necessitate buying new equipment. So it definitely is a good choice to consider for your business.

Conclusion

Dual Pricing presents a compelling option for businesses aiming to optimize their financial operations, especially when grappling with credit card processing fees. By offering distinct price points for cash and card transactions, Dual Pricing not only incentivizes cash payments but also offers customers more transparent choices.

While the strategy offers clear advantages in terms of cost reduction and profitability, it’s crucial for businesses to understand legal considerations and customer perceptions carefully. Understanding your customer base, assessing payment habits, and ensuring compliance with relevant laws are essential steps before implementing Dual Pricing. Ultimately, while Dual Pricing can be a beneficial strategy for many businesses, thoughtful planning and execution are key to leveraging its potential benefits effectively.

Frequently Asked Questions