In 2015, Dollar Tree purchased Family Dollar for $9 billion, a significant transaction in the discount retail industry. This acquisition allowed both companies to extend their market presence and combine their capabilities to improve business operations and customer outreach. So, did Family Dollar and Dollar Tree merge? Let us find out.
Almost ten years later, Dollar Tree is considering different strategic options for Family Dollar, including a potential sale or a separation of the business. J.P. Morgan Securities has been appointed to oversee this strategic review.
Rick Dreiling, the chairman, and CEO of Dollar Tree, mentioned in the company’s first-quarter analyst call last week that the review would determine whether having separate management teams for each brand would better meet their specific needs, addressing Family Dollar’s ongoing challenges and propelling Dollar Tree’s growth.
Source: Statista – Net sales of Family Dollar (Dollar Tree) in the United States from fiscal year 2017 to 2022, by product category
Key Takeaways
- Acquisition and Market Strategy: In 2015, Dollar Tree acquired Family Dollar for $9 billion, aiming to expand its market presence and combine capabilities to improve operations and customer outreach. Dollar Tree targets middle-income customers, while Family Dollar serves lower-income shoppers.
- Ongoing Strategic Review: Dollar Tree is considering various strategic options for Family Dollar, including a potential sale or separation. J.P. Morgan Securities oversees the review to determine if separate management teams would better address each brand’s needs and challenges.
- Challenges Facing Family Dollar: Family Dollar faces significant challenges, including poor store conditions, decreased spending due to inflation, and cuts to SNAP benefits. These issues have led to store closures and increased competition from retailers like Dollar General.
- Efforts and Future Plan: Despite the challenges, efforts are underway to improve Family Dollar’s performance, including assessing and addressing underperforming stores, enhancing store conditions, and installing more coolers for refrigerated goods. The leadership remains optimistic about the potential for growth and transformation.
History of Family Dollar and Dollar Tree
Strategic expansions and significant acquisitions have driven the development of Family Dollar and Dollar Tree, turning these companies into key players in the discount retail sector.
Family Dollar began in 1959 when Leon Levine opened the first store in Charlotte, North Carolina. The store aimed to offer quality products priced below $2. Throughout the 1960s, Family Dollar expanded across the southern United States, and by 1970, the company was publicly listed and had grown to over 200 locations.
Dollar Tree was founded in 1986 by Macon Brock, Doug Perry, and Ray Compton. Originally named Only $1.00, the business focused on selling items at a fixed price. It was renamed Dollar Tree Stores, Inc. in 1993 and listed on the stock market in 1995. The company grew significantly, highlighted by its acquisition of Dollar Bills, Inc. in 1996, which added 136 stores and allowed it to expand into new regions.
By 2015, Dollar Tree had acquired Family Dollar for about $9 billion, solidifying its status as a significant player in the discount retail market. This acquisition marked a substantial shift in its business strategy to include multiple price points in its retail offerings. After the merger, Dollar Tree managed both brands, leveraging their unique strengths to cater to different customer segments.
Dollar Tree targets middle-income customers in suburban areas, primarily selling party favors and seasonal decorations. On the other hand, Family Dollar provides a broader selection of products, including groceries and cleaning supplies, and serves lower-income shoppers in urban and rural settings. Most items at Dollar Tree are priced at $1.25, whereas Family Dollar features a broader spectrum of prices.
The acquisition of Family Dollar was anticipated to allow Dollar Tree to cut costs and improve its competitiveness against rivals like Dollar General, which had also made an offer for the chain and other discount retailers, including Walmart. However, the benefits expected from this merger fell below expectations.
Dollar Tree has announced the closure of nearly 1,000 Family Dollar stores and a few Dollar Tree locations, with plans to shut these stores by the middle of the year.
Family Dollar Faces Challenges Amid Store Closures and Competition
Image source
Years of poor management and substandard store conditions have damaged Family Dollar’s reputation. Inflation, at its highest in decades, has also significantly affected consumers, leading to decreased spending that has impacted Family Dollar customers and the chain’s profits. This has intensified its competition with other discount retailers like Dollar General, Walmart, and more.
Furthermore, cuts to the SNAP benefits program have left many families with up to $250 less each month. Both discount retailers and consumer goods companies have reported feeling the effects of this reduction.
Rick Dreiling, Chairman & Chief Executive Officer, stated that ongoing inflation and decreased government benefits put financial stress on the lower-income consumers who comprise a significant portion of Family Dollar’s customer base.
As mentioned, Dollar Tree revealed the closure of 1,000 stores on March 13, out of which 600 will be Family Dollar stores in the first half of 2024. Additionally, over the coming years, 370 Family Dollar and 30 Dollar Tree stores will be closed as their leases expire. These closures are part of a detailed review of the store portfolio conducted at the end of 2023 to assess market conditions and the performance of each store.
Analysts note that Family Dollar’s stores were in poorer condition than anticipated. Despite renovations, many locations remain in disrepair, understaffed, and with cluttered aisles.
Issues at Family Dollar extend beyond poor store conditions. The company, along with others like Dollar Tree and Dollar General, faces significant security challenges. Stores are often staffed minimally, leading to violent incidents and robberies.
Dollar Tree has also been criticized for unsafe working conditions, and last year, OSHA condemned the company for neglecting worker safety, implying that profit was prioritized over people’s well-being.
This year, Family Dollar faced a severe penalty for safety violations. For selling products from a rat-infested warehouse, it received a $41.6 million fine—the highest in a food safety case. This incident underscored the company’s ongoing challenges.
Turning the focus to Dollar General, it has recently experienced significant growth. Dollar General plans to open about 800 stores this year, making it the fastest-growing retailer in the country after reaching the 20,000th store mark.
Both companies compete for the same demographic of low-income consumers. Although their names suggest dollar pricing, these stores primarily sell food and daily necessities between $1 and $10.
However, Family Dollar has been losing market share to Dollar General, mainly due to pricing differences: items at Family Dollar can be priced 10% to 15% higher than those at Dollar General and other similar discount stores. With more than twice the number of stores, Dollar General’s larger scale allows it to offer lower prices.
Despite these challenges, Dreiling remains optimistic about Family Dollar’s future, citing ongoing efforts to streamline operations and other initiatives aimed at growth, including installing more coolers for refrigerated and frozen goods.
Dollar Tree also recently announced plans to assess all Family Dollar locations to identify and address underperforming stores.
Dreiling expressed continued confidence in Family Dollar and its progress. He praised the team for effectively implementing strategies intended to support sustained growth. He explained that the challenge lies in managing two brands at different stages of development. While Dollar Tree’s focus is on accelerating growth, Family Dollar’s plan is to position it for growth through significant transformation.
About Dollar Tree
Dollar Tree, Inc. operates two primary business segments: Dollar Tree and Family Dollar. The Dollar Tree segment sells items for $1.25 each, offering a mix of consumable products such as household supplies, food items, personal care products, and frozen foods. It also carries a variety of goods, including toys, housewares, party items, stationery, craft supplies, and seasonal products for holidays like Easter, Christmas, and Halloween. The stores operate under the Dollar Tree and Dollar Tree Canada brands, and the company has distribution centers in both the United States and Canada.
The Family Dollar segment features general merchandise discount stores that sell consumables such as food, beverages, personal and healthcare items, tobacco, household cleaning products, and automotive supplies. This segment also offers household items, home decor, bedding, apparel, accessories, footwear, and electronics. Seasonal products for major holidays are available alongside personal electronics like prepaid cell phones and related services. Established in 1986, Dollar Tree, Inc. is headquartered in Chesapeake, Virginia.
About Family Dollar
Family Dollar Stores, Inc., known as Family Dollar, manages over 6,800 general merchandise retail discount stores across 44 states. The stores target local customers, offering a broad range of products at affordable prices. Family Dollar’s product selection spans multiple categories, including home items, consumables, apparel, accessories, seasonal items, and electronics. The company emphasizes a compact, strategically chosen range of merchandise featuring essentials like health and beauty aids, packaged foods, refrigerated items, household cleaning products, stationery, seasonal decorations, and clothing and home decor.
Family Dollar operates its stores on a self-service model, maintaining low operating costs that allow for moderate pricing. In the fiscal year that concluded on August 28, 2010, Family Dollar introduced or updated several of its own brands—the company opened two hundred new stores, shut down seventy, relocated thirteen, expanded fifteen, and renovated eighty-nine stores.
Conclusion
The 2015 acquisition of Family Dollar by Dollar Tree marked a significant step in the discount retail sector. While it aimed to expand market reach and enhance operations, the integration has faced challenges. Family Dollar’s issues, such as poor store conditions and increased competition, have led Dollar Tree to consider strategic alternatives, including a potential sale or separation.
With J.P. Morgan Securities overseeing the review, Dollar Tree’s leadership evaluates whether separate management teams could better address each brand’s needs. Despite these challenges, efforts to improve Family Dollar’s performance continue, with an optimistic outlook for future growth and transformation under targeted strategies.
