Why Is WhatsApp Banned in China?

Why Is WhatsApp Banned in China?

Posted: August 19, 2024 | Updated:

Globally, WhatsApp is a popular messaging app for connecting with friends, family, and various groups. However, this isn’t the case in China. So, why is WhatsApp banned in China and prohibited under the country’s strict internet censorship regulations? Following directives from China’s internet regulatory authority citing national security issues, Apple also pulled WhatsApp and Threads from its App Store in China.

You are wrong if you think Threads and WhatsApp are alone in this. Other social media platforms like Signal and Instagram are banned in China. This restriction is part of a widespread ban on foreign internet services, often called the Great Firewall, which limits the digital interaction of Chinese users with the global community.

But what is the motive behind the ban on WhatsApp? As an end-to-end encrypted messaging app, what harm does it pose that China banned it over six years ago?

Key Takeaways
  • WhatsApp has been banned in China since 2017 due to the government’s strict internet censorship and concerns over its end-to-end encryption.
  • The ban on WhatsApp aligns with China’s broader effort to block foreign social media platforms, reinforcing the Great Firewall and limiting access to global communications.
  • The Chinese government favors domestic platforms like WeChat, which allows easier surveillance and aligns with state policies.
  • Using a VPN can temporarily bypass the ban on WhatsApp in China, but it may expose users to legal scrutiny and risks under local laws.

Understanding Why Is WhatsApp Banned in China

Understanding Why Is WhatsApp Banned in China

Since 1949, China has been governed by the Chinese Communist Party (CCP), an authoritarian regime that controls various aspects of life, including internet access. In 1998, the Chinese government established the Great Firewall, a comprehensive internet filtering system designed to censor and surveil online activities, blocking any services considered harmful to its objectives.

The ban on WhatsApp in China is part of a broader government initiative to regulate social media messaging applications that intensified in 2009. WhatsApp, a Meta-owned platform (previously Facebook), was the last to face a ban, following Facebook in 2009 and Instagram in 2014. China has actively worked to block other major global social media platforms, like Twitter (now X) and Google. This list has expanded over the years to include a variety of websites and apps.

WhatsApp’s situation in China is unique because it is mainly used on mobile devices. Although WhatsApp also provides desktop applications, similar to Instagram in China, it is predominantly used on smartphones. In September 2017, media outlets reported that China blocked WhatsApp, citing national security concerns.

Censorship on WhatsApp began in July of that year when users experienced issues sending and receiving multimedia, voice, and video calls. Issues with text messages soon followed while accessing the internet within China.

The Chinese government maintains tight control over information flow within its borders using a Great Firewall. This digital blockade prevents access to foreign websites and apps, including WhatsApp. The main reason is to block information that the government considers sensitive or potentially disruptive. WhatsApp’s end-to-end encryption presents a challenge because it hinders the government’s ability to monitor and filter communications. Many governments request that such apps create “backdoors” in their encryption to facilitate the monitoring of messages and calls “for national security reasons.”

The motive behind these measures is apparent: the authorities seek to control the flow of information and suppress potential adversaries by accessing data on platforms like WhatsApp.

Therefore, the authorities favor platforms like WeChat, which allow easier surveillance and control and ensure that the content conforms to state policies.

WeChat extends beyond simple messaging; it’s a comprehensive platform incorporating payment systems, social media capabilities, and more, all under governmental oversight. This approach is part of China’s broader objective to achieve technological independence. By restricting foreign competitors, China fosters the growth of domestic firms in a secure market environment, diminishing its dependence on Western technologies.

A Brief Look at the ‘National Security’ Issues That Led to the Ban

A Brief Look at the ‘National Security’ Issues That Led to the Ban

The Chinese government cited national security as another major factor in banning WhatsApp. The Communist Party of China is intensifying its grip on internet use within the country through extensive censorship of sensitive subjects on social media and increased surveillance of communications. The government has also introduced initiatives to limit the duration of internet usage by children.

The specifics of the national security concerns prompting these measures remain undefined. The Chinese authorities have expressed concerns that foreign entities could use the app to disseminate propaganda, coordinate activities that could threaten state stability, or facilitate espionage. WhatsApp’s encryption makes it difficult for Chinese security agencies to intercept messages, raising fears that the platform could be exploited for purposes that conflict with national interests.

China has tightened its grip on Internet activities even further in recent years. For instance, in 2024, China introduced new regulations requiring all apps to register with the government, allowing the authorities greater oversight and control. WhatsApp and other apps like Telegram, Threads, and Signal did not comply with these regulations, which recently led to their removal from Chinese app stores like Apple’s.

A spokesperson for Apple recently stated that the company must comply with the laws of the countries in which it operates, even if they disagree with them. The Cyberspace Administration of China has directed the removal of certain apps from Apple’s China app store, citing national security concerns, though these apps are still available in other markets.

Duncan Clark, chairman of Beijing-based investment advisory BDA China, commented that Apple’s action marks a further separation between the technological landscapes within China and the rest of the world. He noted that this removal could disrupt connections for consumers and businesses in China who communicate with contacts abroad. Even if individuals use VPNs to access services like WhatsApp, these apps will eventually become outdated without regular updates.

Meanwhile, other popular Western social media platforms such as X (formerly known as Twitter), Facebook, Instagram, and Messenger are accessible through Apple’s app store in China.

Can You Unblock WhatsApp in China?

While WhatsApp remains officially banned in China, there have been sporadic reports of the app becoming temporarily accessible. These instances often lead to speculation about policy shifts or technical glitches in enforcing the ban. However, such occurrences are usually short-lived, and access is quickly blocked again–meaning there is no chance that you can unblock WhatsApp in China unless or otherwise, the order of unblock comes directly from the Communist Party of China.

However, if you are considering traveling there for a short time (or even if you live in China), you’ll need to find an alternative method to access certain services; many opt to use a virtual private network (VPN). A reliable VPN encrypts your internet traffic, allowing access to services like WhatsApp while preventing detection by authorities.

As mentioned above, it may not be the permanent solution, but it could be the go-to solution for using WhatsApp in China.

Step 1: Choosing the Right VPN

 Choosing the Right VPN

When selecting a VPN for use in China, it’s essential to pick a provider known for successfully bypassing the Great Firewall. Look for a VPN that offers robust privacy features, a wide range of server locations, and compatibility across multiple operating systems. Verify that the VPN has a proven track record of stable performance in restrictive environments and adheres to a strict no-logs policy to protect your privacy.

The VPNs we recommend are:

  • ExpressVPN
  • NordVPN
  • PureVPN
  • PrivateVPN
  • Surf Shark

These can unblock apps like WhatsApp thanks to their ability to refresh server IPs and use obfuscation techniques quickly. Ensure the VPN offers robust security features, including military-grade encryption, a no-logs policy, DNS leak protection, and a kill switch to prevent data leaks. Despite the inevitable slowdown due to encryption, the top VPNs minimize this impact significantly, maintaining relatively fast speeds.

Opt for a VPN with a vast server network, preferably with servers in 50+ countries and locations near China, like Japan, South Korea, or Malaysia, to enhance speed and reliability. Choose a user-friendly VPN with intuitive apps for all major platforms, allowing easy server connections within seconds. Finally, ensure good value with affordable plans and generous money-back guarantees, ensuring a risk-free purchase.

Step 2: Installing Your VPN

Begin by visiting the VPN provider’s official website. Create an account and choose a subscription plan that aligns with your needs. Select and download the appropriate version of the VPN software for your device, such as Android, iOS, Windows, or macOS. Complete the installation by following the detailed VPN service steps, including setting configuration preferences to optimize performance and security.

Step 3: Connecting to a Server Outside China

Open the installed VPN application and log in with your credentials. Choosing a server location outside of China—opting for nearby regions like Hong Kong or Taiwan can lead to faster and more stable connections. Connect to the server by selecting it within the app, ensuring it’s configured to effectively reroute your internet traffic through that location.

Step 4: Downloading WhatsApp

Since WhatsApp might not be accessible through Chinese app stores, obtain it from a trusted source. The most secure options are downloading directly from the official WhatsApp website or a well-known third-party app store that ensures verified applications. Follow the typical installation process for your device and approve all necessary permissions to enable the app’s complete functionality.

Step 5: Using WhatsApp in China with a VPN

Once the VPN runs, launch WhatsApp and connect to a server outside of China. This configuration lets you circumvent local internet restrictions and access WhatsApp without limitations. Verify your account using your phone number to enable all functionalities, such as messaging, voice and video calls, and sharing media. Keep the VPN active during your WhatsApp sessions to ensure continuous access and to secure your communications within China.

Remember to maintain your VPN connection when using WhatsApp to avoid disruptions and protect your privacy from monitoring.

Is It Safe to Use a VPN in China?

Using a VPN in China could present certain risks. Though not illegal, using a VPN exposes users to potential legal scrutiny. Chinese authorities can use anything you communicate online as evidence against you if it violates local laws.

During travel within China, such as crossing borders or moving between cities, you may be required to surrender your smartphone for inspection. Authorities may search for illegal content or signs of VPN use, typically employed to circumvent the Great Firewall.

While using a VPN in China isn’t illegal or dangerous, it introduces several other potential complications. Exercise caution with what you share online while in the country.

Conclusion

The ban on WhatsApp in China reflects the government’s broader strategy to control information flow and maintain social stability through tight internet censorship. By blocking apps with strong encryption like WhatsApp, the Chinese authorities aim to prevent unmonitored communication that could threaten state security. Instead, the government promotes domestic platforms like WeChat, which are more easily monitored and regulated.

While a VPN offers a workaround, it carries legal risks, and users must exercise caution. The situation underscores China’s commitment to technological self-sufficiency and its ongoing efforts to limit foreign influence on its internet landscape.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. What are the primary reasons WhatsApp has been banned in China?

    WhatsApp is banned in China due to the government’s strict control over communication and information. The app’s end-to-end encryption makes monitoring difficult for the government, which conflicts with China’s internet control policies.

  2. Is WhatsApp the only communication app banned in China?

    No, other messaging apps like Signal and Telegram have also been banned. In 2024, China further enforced this by removing these apps from Apple’s App Store, citing national security concerns.

  3. Have any legal or regulatory developments led to the ban on WhatsApp in China?

    Yes, in August 2024, a law was enacted requiring all app developers to register with the Chinese government, leading to stricter bans on non-compliant apps like WhatsApp.

  4. Can WhatsApp be accessed in China through any alternative methods?

    Some users access WhatsApp using VPNs, but this is risky as VPN use is in a legal gray area in China, and the government actively works to block these tools.

Share This Post

Save Time, Money, & Resources

Categories: Latest News, International

Get Started

Ready for the ultimate credit card processing experience? Fill out this form!

Contact HMS

Ready for the ultimate credit card processing experience? Ask us your questions here.